An independent insurance agent is a licensed agent who is appointed with several insurance companies instead of just one. That means one agent can quote the same house or the same car with more than one company, then help you pick, place the policy and handle the service afterward: changes, billing questions, certificates, claims. The agent is paid a commission by the insurance company that writes the policy, not a separate fee from you. A captive agent does the same work for a single company.

That is the short version. Here is how it works in practice, including the part people don’t usually hear from an agent.

Appointed, not just licensed

Selling insurance in Mississippi takes two things. The first is a producer license from the Mississippi Insurance Department, which the person earns by passing the state exam and keeping up continuing education. The second is an appointment. Under Miss. Code 83-17-75, a producer can’t act as an agent of an insurance company until that company files a notice of appointment with the department, within 15 days of signing the agency contract or receiving the first application. The department’s appointment page lists the fee the company pays: $25 per agent.

An independent agency holds appointments with a number of companies. Each one has looked at the agency, signed a contract and filed it with the state. That stack of appointments is what lets us quote a house in Iuka with more than one company in the same afternoon.

Captive and independent, plainly

The National Association of Insurance Commissioners puts it simply in its guide to choosing an agent. A captive agent sells insurance for only one company. An independent agent may sell policies from many companies. Both represent insurance companies, and both are paid commission by the company.

Neither one is automatically better. A captive agent knows one company’s products deeply and can be a fine fit for someone happy with that company. An independent agent’s advantage shows up when your situation changes, the company raises rates or stops writing in your area, or your house or business doesn’t fit one company’s appetite. Then there is somewhere else to go without starting over with a new agent.

A broker is a third kind of producer. The NAIC describes a broker as representing the buyer, usually for more complicated transactions such as coverage for a small business, and notes that because the broker represents you, brokers generally charge a fee.

The wrinkle most people miss

On paper, an independent agent is an appointed agent of each company it represents. That is what the statute says. Day to day, the work runs toward the customer, shopping the policy, reading it, chasing a claim. Both are true at once, and it is worth knowing both.

The other limit is plainer. An independent agent can only quote the companies it is appointed with. No agency in northeast Mississippi represents every insurer in the state, us included. If a company we don’t represent would be a better fit for you, we can’t place it.

Common questions

Who does an independent insurance agent work for?

Legally, the agent is appointed by each insurance company it represents. In practice, an independent agent shops several of those companies for one customer and handles that customer’s service and claims, whichever company writes the policy.

Is it worth using an independent insurance agent?

It depends on what you value. People who want one place to compare several companies, and someone to call when the policy changes or a claim comes up, tend to get the most from an independent agent. People loyal to one company may be well served by that company’s own agent.

Does it cost more to buy through an agent?

Independent and captive agents are both paid commission by the insurance company rather than charging the customer a separate fee. The NAIC is candid that some policies bought directly online may be less expensive, since the company doesn’t pay an agent’s commission. Whether that holds for a given house or car depends on the company, and on what the direct policy leaves out.

Talk to an agent who shops

If you want to see what more than one company would do with your home, car or business, start with our home insurance page or request a quote. Call or text 662-454-7831 and we’ll walk through it from our Tupelo, Iuka or Belmont office. For more on telling a good policy from a low price, see what separates a low price from a good policy, and for why your phone rings after an online quote, see how lead vendors sell your data.

This article is general information about how coverage typically works, not advice about your specific situation. Your policy is the contract, and it’s the only thing that says what you have. If you’d like someone to read it with you, that’s what we’re here for.